The Treaty of 1921 that partitioned Ireland into two sectarian statelets was, at worst, a betrayal of Irish aspirations and, at best, a temporary solution to avoid an all-out war, as claimed by its signatories and supporters.  After nearly a century of political and economic chaos, it is obvious that the Treaty was flawed, and is in fact the root cause of the ongoing war.  Therefore, it is now time to repeal the Treaty and replace it with a new agreement wherein the British would concede Irish sovereignty, thus clearing the way for the Irish people of both traditions to unite in one free and independent nation.

Developed by Tomas Coisdealba

To this end, Éire Nua is proposing the establishment of a Constituent Assembly as the first step in the process.  The proposed Assembly would draft a new 32-county all-Ireland Constitution that would:

  1. establish political and popular sovereignty for the protection of human rights and social justice;
  2. establish a new government structure based on a federation of the four historic provinces of Ireland, and
  3. establish an independent judiciary.

The convening of a Constituent Assembly is a logical first step in a process designed to bring peace, unity, and prosperity to Ireland.  It offers the prospect of a permanent solution, as opposed to the failed Sunningdale, Hillsdale, GFA and St. Andrews initiatives put forward by the British and Dublin governments.  The proposal is not new, nor is it radical.  It is, in fact, similar in many respects to the 1787 Constitutional Convention convened in Philadelphia to draft a new federal constitution for the emerging United States of America.

Since that time, many other emerging nations came into existence through a similar process.  A prime present-day example is South Africa, a country where the vast majority of its people have been enslaved by a descendant colonist minority.  Many felt this situation would never change, but South Africa today is a country in transition.

The road towards a peaceful Ireland is fraught with obstacles, inherent and protected in the political and economic status quo.  In this climate, any proposal guaranteeing equal rights and opportunity to all the people of Ireland is not welcome.  The initiatives put forward by the British and Dublin governments are minor revisions to the Treaty of 1921, primarily intended to perpetuate the status quo, and therefore destined to end in failure.

The proposed Constituent Assembly would be representative of the whole people of  Ireland and would be elected by the suffrage of the adult population.  The Assembly’s sole function would be to draft a new Constitution.  The draft Constitution would then be submitted to the people in referendum for acceptance or rejection.  This open democratic process would be more meaningful to the Irish people today than the closed-door meetings held between the same politicians who have failed the people so often in the past.  All elements of Irish society would be free to contest the election for the Assembly.  This approach would ensure that the relations of the Irish people with each other and with the world at large would be determined through free an open debate.

In order for this process to succeed all politicians and political parties, expressing an interest in or concern for Ireland’s future must put aside their differences and participate for the common good.  In addition, all those individuals and political parties now excluded must be included in the process and allowed access to the media.  If for no other reason, the Irish people deserve the opportunity to participate in such a process.


Éire Nua a New Constitution: An Independent Judiciary, Part 4 of 5

Developed by Tomas Coisdealba
Developed by Tomas Coisdealba

Welcome to Part 4 of a look at the New Constitution, the Independent Judiciary, on the New Ireland Podcast.  This podcast is brought to you by the Éire Nua US Campaign Committee.

Having marked the 100th anniversary of the First Irish Dáil  Éireann, it is historically meaningful to start universal discussions on an All-Ireland, democratically based, united, federal Irish Republic.

Specifically, the time is now to discuss the New Ireland government envisioned by Éire Nua authors in 1971.  The provincial government model was favorably received by unionist, and nationalist leaders, church leaders and other political party leaders at that time. Unfortunately, the constructive, democratic, movement was banned by the British, allowing the war to continue and over 3600 lives killed.

Now, the presentation of the proposed government structures will embody a system of power-sharing administered at the national, provincial, regional and district government levels.  This system will ensure the maximum distribution of governmental powers and will accommodate the unique and distinctive character of each of the historic provinces.  In addition to the above advantages, it grants autonomy to each of the provinces to pursue interests for which they have natural affinity including cultural, traditional, and economic interests.

Our discussion continues with a look at the New Constitution, the Independent Judiciary, Part 4 of 5.  This is presented by Éire Nua Committee Member Maggie Trainer from NY.

(Special Note: The Éire Nua US Committee podcast production would not be possible without the guidance, research, interpretations and numerous papers written or provided by Tomas and Mike Coisdealba, founders of the Éire Nua movement in the United States.)






What is the Éire Nua US Campaign?



The mission of the Éire Nua US Campaign is to secure the support of the United States Congress and House of Representatives to end the partition of Ireland in the context of a British withdrawal from the six occupied Irish counties to be followed by the establishment of a 32-county Federal Irish Republic as outlined in the Éire Nua document.20140318_042126Introduction

Tip O’Neill, the Speaker of the US House of Representatives, endorsed Éıre Nua in 1973. In 1978, then Chairman of the House Judiciary Committee Representative Peter Rodino, commissioned a fact-finding delegation to investigate the U.S. State Department denial of visas to individuals advocating solutions to the conflict in the British occupied six Irish counties, commonly referred to as Northern Ireland (NI), to enter the United States.  Representatives Joshua Eilberg and Hamilton Fish IV led the delegation that visited Ireland to interview the individuals denied visas to determine if there were legitimate reasons for the State Department’s action. The report published by the delegation found no legal basis for the State Departments actions and concluded that the denials of visas were a political decision made on behest of the London government who feared an airing of their neo-colonial policy in Ireland.

Ruaırí Ó Brádaıgh, the co-author of Éıre Nua, was amongst those individuals denied entry visas.

Contrary to the State Department’s assessment and consequent regressive visa policy pro-British unionists in NI viewed the Éire Nua policy proposals as a genuine attempt at Irish unity and reconciliation. In a paradoxical act of treachery, corrupt elements within the Provisional Sınn Féın (PSF) Northern Command abandoned Éıre Nua stating that it was a “sop to the Unionists.” Despite Provisional Sınn Féın’s despicable rejection of the Éire Nua policy, republican parties and dedicated individuals in Ireland and in the U.S. “kept the flag a flying” for the past four decades. 

What is Éire Nua?

Éire Nua, initially proposed by Republican Sinn Féin in 1972, would, as a basic requirement, reunite the British occupied six counties of Ireland with the rest of Ireland in an all-Ireland federation comprised of the four historic provinces of Ulster, Munster, Leinster, and Connacht. This comprehensive and far-reaching policy is in stark contrast to British imposed arrangements such as the Anglo-Irish Treaty of 1921, Sunningdale, Hillsborough, and the Good Friday Agreement, all calculated to copper-fasten and legitimize British control over the occupied six counties of Ireland.  If enacted it would act as a bulwark against what everyone fears – another war.

Éire Nua is not imposed, it is proposed.  It is non-sectarian and inclusive.